Tuesday, September 8, 2009

That which we cannot change


Numerous times since Saturday I've reminded myself of the aphorism attributed to St. Francis of Assisi about having the grace to accept the things you can't change. The thing my wife and I can't change is the loss of a backdrop of trees that were cut from our neighbor's yard. She has blogged about it here. Our side yard ends at a board fence, but that otherwise plain and homely fence was softened and graced by the low-hanging boughs of trees that hung over the top of the fence. Those overhanging boughs provided us dogwood blossoms in spring and colorful leaves in the fall. The contrasting red dogwood and yellow sassafras leaves, along with some shiny green magnolia leaves in the background created a certain charm and framed the plantings and decorations we had placed at the edge of our yard. (The photo above was taken last fall.) In a day of work with a crew of hired hands, our neighbor took out all the trees between our fence and his house, leaving only three tall pines, which we fear will also be cut.
All of the trees that were cut were on the neighbor's property. He was within his rights to cut the trees, despite my feeble hints, after the chainsawing began, that we really wished he'd keep the trees. This Tree City USA provides little protection for trees, which add so much to the flavor of a neighborhood. A Facebook post recently complained that the city had cut down three trees, with trunks 3 or 4 feet in diameter, in one block. The city can protect trees in the utility strip next to the curb — or not. But it cannot dictate to property owners what they do with trees on their property.
Perhaps some regulation of tree cutting would be appropriate. A neighbor recently commented that she had not realized what an across-the-street neighbor's cutting of some trees in his yard would mean to her. Those tall trees had shaded her front windows from the afternoon sun. When Hurricane Fran in 1996 took out several trees in our old neighborhood, we discovered how much those trees' shade had meant to us. Suddenly our front rooms were subjected to afternoon glare, even though the fallen trees had not been on our property. Wilson now has only one major street — the 700-800 blocks of Raleigh Road — with a canopy of trees. A couple of decades ago, Tarboro Street between the railroad tracks and Ward Boulevard was canopied, but those beautiful old oaks were cut down when the street was widened. A few residential streets are canopied, but most of these trees are aging and will need to be replaced.
The city requires building permits and demolition permits, why not tree-cutting permits for trees of a certain trunk diameter or height? Even when these trees are on private property, their presence affects nearby properties.
Nothing can be done to replace the neighboring trees we lost, and I'm trying to accept that which I cannot change, but some regulation of tree cutting might save the trees that give neighborhoods the shade and charm that are so precious — and so easily lost.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

permits to cut down trees on your own property? Come on. The city requires a $75 demolition permit just to take a shed down and you want them to make more stupid money off of us?

Anonymous said...

The idea isn't for the city to make money. The idea is for city government to provide some protection for things that benefit all, but not all appreciate. The permit fee could be minimal -- just enough to cover the redtape cost.

Sorry about your trees. I hope the neighbor will leave the pines for you.

Anonymous said...

yes, penalties.
Enough to cover red tape. That is why we have problems in the world today. Red tape. Just think how much $$$ we could be saving if we had NO red tape!


Individual libertites flew out the door in the 1970's.

Anonymous said...

i miss my shade trees hurricane fran blew down.
Wonder if she would have been required to get a city permit to destroy?

Anonymous said...

I'm not much of a fan when it comes to having other people tell us what we can and can't do with our property. You want trees next to your fence? Plant them. Had it been up to you, the neighbor likely would have been unable to cut his trees. How about if he wanted your fence to come down. That OK?

Erstwhile Editor said...

OK, Anonymous # 5: the loss of my neighbors' trees is more than a personal choice by a property owner. Cutting trees that cannot be replaced for another 30 or 40 years (long after I'm gone) is an irreversible decision. It's not like he painted his house purple; that can be undone. Destroying 80-foot trees cannot be undone in my lifetime, or his. Cutting those trees affects our entire neighborhood and likely reduces the resale value of every house in the neighborhood. Stately trees give a neighborhood its character and enhance property values. Should one person be allowed to arbitrarily damage the lifetime investments of neighbors all around? Sure, we should respect private property, but we should also respect community values and refrain from harming others. I'm planting a tree today and planted two yesterday, but those little trees cannot replace the 80-foot pines and 15-foot dogwoods that were demolished.

word99 said...

Ok while trees are pretty and add to the beautification of wilson it is ultimately the property owners right to do with the property as they please. Actually, trees do alot of damage to driveways, fences, foundations, landscaping, and potentially the house itself. These neighbors you complain of are actually smart to take their trees down. I've lived in a hurricane and storm prone area and when a tree falls on a home or potentially branches fall on people or cars, believe me I wish in many instances those people cut down there trees before this happened. When it comes to damage to a home or car or a person, a tree is not worth saving. I hope these neighbors would be willing to pay the thousands of dollars of damage the trees would have caused. Or why don't the mad neighbors plant a tree for every tree they cut down. Get over and quit writing blogs! So Hippies go back to wooodstock and hug your neighbors, let them do as they please, otherwise shut up and be willing to pay their damage or pro create a new life for the damage or death these trees could have caused.